LSF/MM 2018

| categories: fedora

Wheee LSF/MM. Highlights.

  • There were a couple of sessions related to everyone's favorite mitigation, PTI. Unsurprisingly, PTI has an impact on I/O heavy workloads because it makes system calls more expensive. Minimizing system calls has always been good performance advice, and it only becomes more important with PTI. Also important is to make sure features like the vDSO are used since that helps to mitigate the system call cost. There was some discussion about if we need new system calls that take vectors to help with TLB flushing costs (e.g. multiple madvise calls will require a flush each time).

  • Ted Ts'o gave a session on fs-verity. This is a file system feature for file integrity that's mostly been focused on Android. The functionality is similar to what IMA wants to provides but focuses on immutable files. Looks promising.

  • Speaking of IMA, Mimi Zohar gave a presentation on IMA with a focus on file system topics. The goal of IMA is to provide cryptographic verification of files with keys tied to the TPM. The nature of this means it ends up touching file system internals and some things it perhaps shouldn't (e.g. file system magic numbers). There's been good progress towards making IMA more acceptable toward everyone.

  • Igor Stoppa talked about protectable dynamic memory (called pmalloc). The goal is to allow read only protection of memory that can't be statically allocated. This is a patch series I've been reviewing/following for some time now. Overall, feedback seemed promising for it to get merged soon.

  • I talked briefly about CMA (my primary reason for attending). CMA relies on alignment to pageblock size since it is tied to migration. On arm64 with 64K pages, the pageblock size gets bumped to 512MB which is a bit much. I discussed some approaches to loosening that requirements. The two big options are either just make the pageblock size smaller if we aren't using THP or just let CMA exist as a subpageblock region (some patches were recently merged by Joonsoo Kim to make this much easier). Both are plausible, now all I need to do is write the code (alas).

  • Matthew Wilcox talked about struct page. Kernel documentation has been notoriously lacking for internal APIs and structures. A struct page exists for each page of memory on the system which means it needs to be compact as possible. The end result is a difficult to understand structure. Matthew proposed re-arraging the structure to better clarify the actual usage and make it clear what fields of the structure outside users could actually use. It seemed to be well received so I expect to see it on the mailing list sometime.

  • I got a chance to chat with some Red Hat people about dm-vdo. I had seen this discussed internally somewhat before but the hallway track provided a much better explanation to me of both the details of the code and some of the potential pitfalls. The hallway track is always great.

LWN already has some coverage up but watch there for much better details on all the sessions.